Last Updated on: 17th May 2024, 05:57 pm
J Highland
J Highland is a certified sommelier with 30 years in the liquor industry, owning a pub, a liquor store, and moonlighting as an agave spirits distiller.
With the assistance of Tequila expert Neil Coleman and customer feedback, I have assembled a list of the top Tequilas for Long Island Iced Tea.
Written by: J Highland
Choosing the Best Tequila for a Long Island Iced Tea

- Best Tequila for Long Island Iced Tea: Blanco or Silver Tequilas are ideal for mixing in Long Island Iced Teas, with their neutral flavor profiles blending well in the cocktail. Affordable Tequilas are recommended for experimentation without remorse.
- Top Tequilas for Long Island Iced Tea: El Padrino Blanco, Gonzalez 1939, Camarena Silver, Altos Plata, and Milagro Silver are recommended choices due to their flavor profiles and affordability, making them suitable for blending in this cocktail.
- Quick Note: Running a pub and liquor store provides me ample access to various spirits, in addition, I moonlight as an agave spirits distiller. I assess them using customer feedback, expert opinions and online research.
Quick Look at the Best Tequilas for Long Island Iced Tea
Prices are approximate and stated in USD:
| Tequila | Price |
| El Padrino Blanco | $30 |
| Gonzalez 1939 | $38 |
| Camarena Silver | $19 |
| Altos Plata | $24 |
| Milagro Silver | $22 |
El Padrino: Agave Punch for Your Long Island Iced Tea

El Padrino strikes a balance between affordability and a flavor profile ideal for Long Island Iced Teas. While not the smoothest tequila for sipping neat, it delivers a lively mix of agave, sweet tropical fruits, and a peppery bite.
This makes it a perfect choice for cocktails like the Long Island Iced Tea, where its bold notes can shine through without overpowering the drink. According to tequila expert Neil Coleman, El Padrino's budget-friendly price tag makes it ideal for experimenting with mixed drinks.
Gonzalez 1939: Budget-Friendly Tequila for Cocktails

Gonzalez 1939 shines in mixed drinks like Margaritas and Long Islands. Its citrusy agave notes with a hint of anise create a unique twist, while its smooth profile makes it easy to sip neat at an affordable price.
Camarena Silver: Budget-Friendly Mixer for Long Island Iced Tea

Camarena Silver's peppery agave profile makes it a great choice for a strong Long Island Iced Tea at an affordable price. While not the smoothest tequila for sipping, its peppery bite mixes well in cocktails.
Olmeca Altos Plata: Earthy Agave for Bold Cocktails

Olmeca Altos Plata's herbal agave, pepper, and vegetal notes make it a standout mixer for Long Island Iced Teas. While intriguing for sipping, its bold profile truly shines in cocktails.
Milagro Silver: Affordable Warmth for Mixed Drinks

Milagro Silver's peppery agave and hint of cinnamon make it a budget-friendly choice for cocktails like Long Islands. While not the smoothest for sipping, its warmth adds depth to mixed drinks.
Choosing the Ideal Tequila for Long Island Iced Tea
- Type of Tequila: Blanco or Silver Tequilas are preferred for their clean, crisp flavors. These Tequilas blend seamlessly in Long Island Iced Teas without overpowering other ingredients.
- Flavor Profile: Choose Tequilas with a neutral profile, avoiding overly complex or aged Tequilas that might clash with the cocktail's other components.
- Affordability: Since Long Island Iced Tea is a mixed drink with multiple spirits, opting for an affordable Tequila makes sense. It allows for experimentation without too much investment.
- Smoothness: Even in a cocktail, the Tequila should be smooth to ensure the drink's overall quality. Harsh or overly alcoholic Tequilas can detract from the cocktail's enjoyment.
- Expert and Customer Recommendations: Take guidance from Tequila experts like Neil Coleman and consider customer feedback for tried-and-tested options.
- Versatility: A versatile Tequila that works well in Long Island Iced Teas can also be a good addition to other cocktails, offering more value for your purchase.
