Best Extra Añejo Tequilas of 2024

Last Updated on: 17th May 2024, 01:11 pm

J Highland

J Highland is a certified sommelier with 30 years in the liquor industry, owning a pub, a liquor store, and moonlighting as an agave spirits distiller.

Explore the finest Extra Añejo Tequilas, a blend of luxury and craftsmanship, in this guide with insights from expert Neil Coleman and customer feedback, showcasing the best of barrel-aging artistry.

Written by: J Highland

Choosing the Best Extra Añejo Tequila

For the agave-forward extra añejo:

• G4 Extra Añejo 55: Agave takes center stage with subtle oak, black pepper, and caramel notes.
• Tapatio Excelencia Extra Añejo: Bold agave presence complemented by apple pie notes, baking spices, caramel, and a touch of oak.
• Siete Leguas D'Antaño Extra Añejo: Rich agave core that stands out against the oak influence.

For the balanced extra añejo:

• Alquimia Extra Añejo: Silky texture and primary agave flavor with hints of dried fruit, vanilla, caramel, and oak.
• Fuenteseca Extra Añejo: Beautiful balance between agave and oak character, with oak giving way to agave, fruit, and caramel notes.
• Suerte Extra Añejo: Unexpected balance with a melody of baking spices, cherry, earthy hints, and agave.

For the affordable extra añejo:

• San Matias Extra Añejo: Budget-friendly introduction with a sweet, smooth taste of caramel and vanilla.
• Casa Noble Single Barrel Extra Añejo: Smooth, flavorful tequila under $100 with caramel, vanilla, hazelnut, oak, and a hint of coconut.

For the unique or distinctive extra añejo:

• Arette Gran Clase Extra Añejo: Bold flavors with a bourbon-like aroma of caramel, vanilla, citrus, and apricot.
• Number Juan Extra Añejo: Unexpected delight with a delicate balance of sweetness and oak, showcasing citrus alongside classic caramel and vanilla notes.
• Rey Sol Extra Añejo: Cognac-inspired sweetness with caramel, vanilla, and oak aromas, offering a dance between sweetness and spice.

For the smooth extra añejo:

• Don Cheyo Extra Añejo: Smooth, dessert-like with a wave of caramel and vanilla transitioning to agave, fruity hints, and oaky spice.
• Casa Noble Single Barrel Extra Añejo: Smoothness a result of triple-distillation and aging in lightly charred French white oak barrels.
• Tears of Llorona Extra Añejo: Luxurious with a light mouthfeel and minimal burn, allowing rich flavors to take center stage.

For the bourbon lover also interested in tequila:

• Herradura Seleccion Suprema Extra Añejo: Offers a unique experience that bridges both worlds with an aroma of caramel, vanilla, oak, and roasted agave.
• Suerte Extra Añejo: Pleasant warmth followed by baking spices, cherry, earthy hints, and of course, agave.

For the tequila aficionado:

• Tears of Llorona Extra Añejo: Luxurious with exceptional quality and complexity, achieving its unique character through aging in Scotch, sherry, and cognac barrels.
• Tapatio Excelencia Extra Añejo: Crafted by the esteemed La Alteña Distillery since 1937, a must-try for those seeking an authentic and flavorful experience.

1. Quick Note: Running a pub and liquor store provides me ample access to various spirits, in addition, I moonlight as an agave spirits distiller. I assess them using customer feedback, expert opinions and online research.

A Quick Look at the Best Extra Añejo Tequilas

Alquimia Extra Añejo: A Celebration of Agave Aged to Perfection

Alquimia Extra Añejo takes a unique approach to añejo tequila, prioritizing the agave spirit's essence. Crafted with 14-year aged, home-grown organic agaves, this premium tequila stands out for its commitment to quality ingredients.

The aroma offers an interesting mix of alcohol notes balanced by hints of agave, dried fruit, vanilla, caramel, and oak. Surprisingly, despite the lengthy aging process, Alquimia Extra Añejo avoids the typical oak-heavy profile found in many añejos. Instead, a silky texture and primary agave flavor take center stage, creating a memorable sipping experience.

This dedication to showcasing the agave shines through, even after 14 years of aging. The combination of exceptional quality and a reasonable price point makes Alquimia Extra Añejo a highly recommended choice for adventurous tequila enthusiasts, states tequila expert Neil Coleman.

Fuenteseca: A Refined Extra Añejo Tequila Experience

Tequila enthusiasts, take note! Fuenteseca Extra Añejo offers a distinctive taste profile thanks to its 7-year aging process. Imagine 80% resting in American oak barrels kissed by California red wine, the rest in dark French oak.

The result? An aroma rich in oak with hints of ripe fruit and agave. The taste is equally complex, with oak giving way to agave, fruit, and caramel notes. Subtle baking spices emerge, leading to a smooth finish with lingering barrel spice and warmth.

Unlike some heavily oak-influenced Extra Añejos, Fuenteseca strikes a beautiful balance, showcasing both agave and barrel character. This premium tequila is a worthy exploration for those seeking a refined sipping experience.

Arette Gran Clase Extra Añejo: Bold Flavors for Agave Aficionados

Arette Gran Clase Extra Añejo promises a distinctive tequila adventure. Expect an aroma like a fine bourbon, with hints of caramel, vanilla, citrus, and apricot. On the palate, it's surprisingly smooth despite its high proof, offering a rich, oily texture.

Agave takes center stage, mingling with vanilla, caramel, and warm baking spices, all supported by oaky undertones. The lengthy aging allows the agave to truly shine, creating a sophisticated sipping experience.

Bottled at a higher proof, it delivers full-bodied flavor, potentially complementing a fine cigar. This all-natural Extra Añejo is priced competitively, making it a tempting choice for tequila lovers.

Patron 10-Year Extra Añejo: Agave-Forward Luxury Tequila

Patron's 10-Year Extra Añejo offers a luxurious tequila experience.

The aroma is captivating, featuring dried fruit, cinnamon, and hints of roasted nuts and butter. The taste is equally impressive, boasting a thick texture and a smooth finish. Agave remains the star, complemented by roasted nuts, oaky notes, and a touch of caramel sweetness.

Uniquely, despite its long aging, the tequila retains a strong agave presence. Oak and nutty notes are present but subtle, avoiding the bourbon-like character found in some aged tequilas. This focus on agave is a hallmark of Patron, but it comes at a premium price.

Siete Leguas D'Antaño Extra Añejo: Balanced Extra Añejo with Rich Agave Character

Siete Leguas' D'Antaño Extra Añejo delivers a satisfying balance between agave and oak. The aroma entices with agave and oak, accented by caramel, vanilla, and dried fruit. On the palate, a luxurious oiliness complements flavors of agave, oak, baking spices like cinnamon and nutmeg, and even a hint of dark chocolate. The finish is smooth and lingers with dried fruit and oak notes.

Aged for five years, D'Antaño showcases a rich agave core that stands out against the oak influence, a hallmark of Siete Leguas tequilas. As expected for a premium tequila, D'Antaño is crafted with no additives, ensuring a pure experience.

Number Juan Extra Añejo: Unexpected Delight from Celebrity Tequila

Number Juan Extra Añejo challenges celebrity tequila stereotypes. This near-decade-aged agave spirit boasts a delightful aroma of vanilla, caramel, orange, and subtle oak. The taste is equally impressive, offering a smooth, oily mouthfeel. Expect a blend of agave, oak, citrus (lime and orange), and caramel, finishing with a touch of black pepper and lingering caramel sweetness.

This offering from comedians Alex Reymundo and Ron White proves genuine quality can emerge from the celebrity tequila world.

The Extra Añejo defies expectations with its delicate balance of sweetness and oak, showcasing a richness in citrus alongside classic caramel and vanilla notes.

G4 Extra Añejo 55: Agave Takes Center Stage

Craving an Extra Añejo where agave reigns supreme? Look no further than G4 Extra Añejo 55. Forget the oak takeover common in many aged tequilas. This 55-month wonder boasts a nose rich in agave, accented by subtle oak, black pepper, and a touch of caramel.

The buttery palate continues the agave focus, complemented by sweet fruit, black pepper, and hints of caramel and aged leather. The long finish brings back the agave and oak, leaving a pleasant warmth. Unlike its three-year-aged counterparts, G4's extended aging subtly integrates oak, allowing the true agave character to shine.

This is a must-try for those seeking a smooth and flavorful Extra Añejo where agave takes center stage.

Rey Sol Extra Añejo: Cognac-Inspired Sweetness in a Stylish Package

Sweet aromas of caramel, vanilla, and oak greet you first with Rey Sol Extra Añejo. The tequila itself boasts a luxurious, oily mouthfeel. The taste is a delightful dance between sweetness and spice. Upfront caramel and honey notes mingle with subtle baking spices like cinnamon and nutmeg, all balanced by a touch of bitter chocolate. The finish lingers with a hint of baking spice and minimal heat.

Aged for six years in French oak barrels, Rey Sol takes inspiration from Cognac, offering a smooth and pleasantly sweet experience.

This beautifully presented bottle, designed by Mexican artist Sergio Bustamante, is a treat for both the eyes and the palate, making it a great choice for those who appreciate a touch of artistry alongside their tequila.

Suerte Extra Añejo: Unexpected Gem for Bourbon and Agave Fans

Surprise awaits in Suerte Extra Añejo! This Single Barrel tequila boasts a unique balance that transcends expectations for a lesser-known brand.

The aroma hints at whiskey with notes of apple pie, honey, vanilla, and oak. The taste is equally surprising, offering a pleasant warmth followed by a melody of baking spices, cherry, earthy hints, and of course, agave. The finish lingers with baking spice sweetness and a mild warmth.

Aged for seven years, Suerte impresses with its subtle oak influence, striking a delightful balance between sweetness and barrel character.

This is a fantastic option for bourbon lovers seeking a familiar whiskey-like experience complemented by the distinct agave character. The affordable price tag adds another layer of appeal, making Suerte Extra Añejo a must-try for adventurous tequila enthusiasts.

Casa Noble Single Barrel: Smooth, Flavorful Extra Añejo Under $100

Casa Noble Single Barrel Extra Añejo is a tempting tequila for under $100.

The aroma entices with a blend of caramel, vanilla, agave, and toasted oak. The taste is equally inviting, offering a smooth, dense texture with flavors of caramel, vanilla, hazelnut, oak, and a hint of coconut. The finish is moderately long, lingering with oak, caramel, and a subtle warmth.

Beware, the allure of Casa Noble's taste can lead to a quickly emptied glass! This impressive Extra Añejo delivers excellent value, particularly for those seeking high-quality tequila without breaking the bank.

The smoothness is a result of triple-distillation and five years of aging in lightly charred French white oak barrels.

San Matias Extra Añejo: Budget-Friendly Introduction to Extra Añejo Tequilas

Looking for an affordable introduction to Extra Añejo tequilas? Look no further than San Matias Extra Añejo. Clocking in at around $50, this tequila punches above its weight.

The aroma starts with agave, then reveals hints of cinnamon, oak, and ripe fruit with a little breathing time. The taste is medium-bodied and easy to sip. Expect a sweet, smooth first impression with caramel and vanilla, transitioning to oak and aged leather notes. The finish lingers pleasantly with a touch of black pepper and caramel sweetness.

While San Matias Extra Añejo might not be agave-forward compared to other Extra Añejos, it offers a delightful and approachable sweetness. This makes it a perfect starting point for those who are new to this style of aged tequila and want to explore the category without a hefty price tag.

Tapatio Excelencia Extra Añejo: Agave-Forward Delight for Tequila Purists

Tapatio Excelencia Extra Añejo speaks to true tequila lovers. The aroma is a symphony of agave, accented by vanilla, caramel, and subtle hints of apple that emerge with time. The body is satisfying without being overly oily.

The taste is where this tequila truly shines. Expect a bold agave presence, complemented by delightful apple pie notes, baking spices, caramel, and a touch of oak. The finish is smooth and long, lingering with almond and subtle oak without any harshness.

What truly sets Tapatio Excelencia apart is its commitment to showcasing genuine agave character. The apple pie notes and subdued oak ensure the agave remains the star of the show.

This additive-free extra añejo tequila, crafted by the esteemed La Alteña Distillery since 1937, is a must-try for those seeking an authentic and flavorful Extra Añejo experience.

Don Cheyo Extra Añejo: Sweet & Affordable

Craving for a smooth dessert-like long-aged tequila? Don Cheyo Extra Añejo might be your perfect match.

While the aroma leans oak-heavy with whispers of agave, caramel, and vanilla, the taste takes a sweeter turn.

Expect a wave of caramel and vanilla on the first sip, transitioning to agave, fruity hints, and a touch of oaky spice. The finish lingers pleasantly with caramel and oak sweetness, avoiding any harshness.

Herradura Seleccion Suprema: Award-Winning Extra Añejo with Bourbon Flair

Tequila enthusiasts and bourbon lovers, take note! Herradura Seleccion Suprema Extra Añejo offers a unique experience that bridges both worlds. The aroma is reminiscent of a fine bourbon, featuring caramel, vanilla, oak, and a hint of roasted agave.

The taste is equally complex, boasting a rich palate of vanilla, oak, leather, tobacco, and dried fruit. The long finish with minimal heat further reinforces the bourbon connection.

This award-winning tequila, recognized as the Best Extra Añejo Tequila in 2014 with a score of 94 points, is a testament to Herradura's 150+ years of tequila-making expertise.

If you're seeking a luxurious and unique sipping experience, or the perfect gift for a tequila aficionado, look no further than Herradura Seleccion Suprema.

Tears of Llorona Extra Añejo: A Luxurious Tequila Experience

Tears of Llorona Extra Añejo stands out as a premium tequila with exceptional quality and complexity. Its deep color hints at the rich flavor profile to come. This high-proof tequila (86) surprises with a light mouthfeel and minimal burn, allowing rich flavors to take center stage.

A perfect balance of smoky and oaky notes mingles with hints of sweetness and spice, creating an ideal sipping tequila. The finish may be brief, but the higher proof adds a touch of warmth to the experience.

Tears of Llorona achieves its unique character through a nearly five-year aging process in Scotch, sherry, and cognac barrels before blending. This special aging contributes to its exceptional smoothness and easy drinkability, despite the higher alcohol content.

Overall, Tears of Llorona isn't just a top-shelf Extra Añejo, it's a contender for one of the finest tequilas available. While the price tag might seem high, tequila enthusiasts will find the quality and flavor justify every penny.

How to Select Good Extra Añejo Tequila?

Selecting a good Extra Añejo Tequila involves understanding the intricacies of aging and flavor. Here are some guidelines to help you make the best choice:

• Understand the Aging Process: Extra Añejo Tequilas are aged for a minimum of three years. This extended aging in barrels imparts complex flavors and a smooth character. Look for tequilas that maintain a balance between the agave essence and the rich nuances from aging.
• Identify Key Flavor Profiles:
  • Seek tequilas that offer a harmonious blend of traditional agave flavors with the deeper, woody notes acquired from barrel aging. For instance, Tears of Llorona is celebrated for its balance of smoky, oaky, and sweet notes.
  • Consider tequilas like Casa Noble Single Barrel for their unique taste profiles, offering a blend of caramel, vanilla, and toasted oak flavors.
• Value for Money: While Extra Añejo Tequilas are generally pricier due to their aging process, it's essential to find one that provides good value. Casa Noble Single Barrel Extra Añejo, for example, is known for its incredible taste and great value.
• Budget Considerations: If you're on a tighter budget, options like San Matías Gran Reserva offer a top choice without breaking the bank.
• Look for Additive-Free Quality: To ensure a pure and authentic tequila experience, opt for Extra Añejo Tequilas that are free from additives. This ensures that the flavors are natural and derived from the aging process and the quality of the agave.
• Brand Reputation and Expertise: Consider the reputation of the brand and the expertise behind it. Reputable brands with a history of quality production are more likely to produce a superior Extra Añejo Tequila.
• Check Customer Reviews and Expert Opinions: Feedback from other tequila enthusiasts and experts can provide valuable insights. Use this as a guide to understand the general reception of the tequila.
• Personal Preference: Ultimately, your taste preference is crucial. Whether you prefer a tequila that leans more towards sweet, fruity notes or one that highlights the oak and spice from the barrel, choose a tequila that aligns with your palate.

Frequently asked questions

A quick FAQ to address your doubts:

What makes a Tequila Extra Añejo special?

Extra Añejo Tequilas are known for their smoothness and rich agave flavor, despite undergoing a long aging process. They are a blend of luxury and craftsmanship, showcasing the best of barrel-aging artistry.

What are some top Extra Añejo Tequila choices?

Leading choices include Tears of Llorona as the best of 2024, Casa Noble Single Barrel for great value, and San Matías Gran Reserva for those on a tight budget.

How much do these Extra Añejo Tequilas cost approximately?

Prices vary, with options like Alquimia Extra Añejo XIV at $240, Patron Extra Añejo 10 Años at $300, and more affordable choices like Casa Noble Single Barrel at $99.

What are some standout features of these Extra Añejo Tequilas?

Each has unique qualities. For example, Tears of Llorona offers an unparalleled sipping experience, while Casa Noble Single Barrel is known for incredible taste and value.

Are these Tequilas suitable for both sipping and special occasions?

Yes, Extra Añejo Tequilas are perfect for sipping and special occasions, offering complex flavors and smoothness ideal for an exquisite drinking experience.

Can Extra Añejo Tequilas rival other premium spirits?

Definitely. These Tequilas are praised for their complex flavors and craftsmanship, rivaling other premium spirits in quality and taste.

Where can I find these Tequilas?

They are generally available at high-end liquor stores or online retailers specializing in premium spirits. Availability may vary.

Who is Neil Coleman?

Neil Coleman is a Tequila expert with over 40 years of experience in the liquor industry, whose insights contribute to the selection and evaluation of these fine Extra Añejo Tequilas.

Are these Tequilas appropriate for Tequila connoisseurs?

Yes, these Extra Añejo Tequilas are not only luxurious but also crafted with attention to detail, making them suitable for connoisseurs and enthusiasts alike.