Last Updated on: 17th May 2024, 05:37 pm
J Highland
J Highland is a certified sommelier with 30 years in the liquor industry, owning a pub, a liquor store, and moonlighting as an agave spirits distiller.
These are the top Tequilas to collect.
They have been chosen by me, assisted by Tequila expert Neil Coleman and customer feedback.
Written by: J Highland
Choosing the Best Tequila to Collect
- Top Collectible Tequilas: 7 Leguas Siete Decadas, Fuenteseca Cosecha 2018, Ocho Reposado Widow Jane, Fortaleza Reposado Winter Blend, ArteNOM 1146 Añejo, Arette Gran Clase Extra Añejo 10 Year, Tears of Llorona Extra Añejo.
- Quick Note: Running a pub and liquor store provides me ample access to various spirits, in addition, I moonlight as an agave spirits distiller. I assess them using customer feedback, expert opinions and online research.
Quick Look at the Best Tequilas to Collect
Prices are approximate and stated in USD:
7 Leguas Siete Decadas Tequila: A Toast to 70 Years of Excellence
Siete Leguas' 7 Decadas celebrates 70 years of tradition with an exceptional tequila crafted using time-honored methods. Agave hearts, grown wild for up to a decade, are slow-roasted in small stone ovens, unlocking their rich, earthy character.
Robust roasted agave takes center stage on the nose, complemented by subtle hints of earth and salinity. Remarkably, there's no harsh alcohol presence to disrupt the harmony.
The first sip reveals a delightful oily texture that caresses the palate. Flavors burst forth, showcasing the cooked agave at its finest. Accents of cinnamon and anise add intrigue, while a touch of black pepper lingers in the background. The long finish is a warming embrace of agave and cinnamon, leaving you wanting more.
This isn't just tequila; it's an experience. Crafted for true tequila enthusiasts, 7 Decadas boasts a natural sweetness that comes from the finest agaves, not additives. It's full-bodied and flavorful, a remarkable journey from the opening scent to the lingering finish, states tequila expert Neil Coleman.
Fuenteseca Cosecha: Redefining Tequila Smoothness
While exceeding your budget, Fuenteseca Cosecha sets a new standard for tequila with its exceptional flavor and unparalleled smoothness.
The aroma entices with a dominant presence of cooked agave, interwoven with earthy tones, a touch of brine, and a subtle hint of black pepper. The first sip lives up to the promise, delivering a burst of agave richness complemented by mineral undertones and a surprising essence of green olives. Hints of mango and papaya add a touch of fruitiness, creating a beautifully complex flavor profile.
Despite its 90-proof strength, Fuenteseca Cosecha boasts an impressively smooth texture, ensuring a luxurious mouthfeel. The finish is equally impressive, lingering long with delicate notes of vanilla and black pepper.
This remarkable tequila challenges expectations by offering vibrant flavors alongside an incredibly smooth and approachable experience. While priced above $100, Fuenteseca Cosecha is a must-try for those seeking an exceptional and unforgettable tequila adventure.
Ocho Widow Jane: A Unique Tequila Adventure
Ocho Widow Jane takes tequila on a unique adventure, aging it in Widow Jane Bourbon barrels. Surprisingly, it doesn't inherit the Dr Pepper-like taste characteristic of bourbon.
The aroma is all about agave, with pronounced notes followed by hints of cinnamon and mint. The first sip reveals an incredibly satisfying mouthfeel - chewy yet smooth. Flavor-wise, expect a robust agave character accented by pecans, cinnamon, and mint, with a subtle earthy undertone emerging later. The finish is long, warming, and leaves a pronounced baking spice kick alongside the expected tequila heat.
This is a great option to add to the tequila collections, and the Camarena craftsmanship assures a quality experience.
Fortaleza Winter Blend: A Reposado Reimagined
Fortaleza Winter Blend breaks the mold for Reposado tequila. It combines a seven-month aged tequila from ex-bourbon barrels with a ten-month aged one from French casks that previously housed Marsala wine, known for its caramelized sweetness.
The aroma starts with cooked agave, but then takes a delightful turn with delicate hints of caramel, oak, and vanilla. The first sip reveals a luxurious, creamy texture bursting with flavors. Ripe fruit sweetness mingles with agave, vanilla, oak, hints of chocolate, and a touch of cinnamon. The finish is long, delightfully sweet, and dominated by vanilla and oak with a gentle warming sensation.
Fortaleza Winter Blend takes the classic Reposado profile and elevates it with the introduction of chocolate and cinnamon notes, creating a richer and sweeter experience. This well-deserved recognition as the Best New Spirit 2020 by the Tales of the Cocktail Foundation is a testament to its innovation and flavor. While exceeding your budget, Fortaleza Winter Blend is a must-try for those seeking a unique and luxurious tequila adventure.
ArteNom 1146: A Premier Añejo for Under $100
ArteNom 1146 breaks the mold for Añejo tequila with a unique aging process. Two years are spent in ex-Cabernet Franc barrels, followed by a year in ex-bourbon barrels. For an added layer of complexity, 40% of the batch spends an additional three years in various casks. This approach results in a tequila rich with dried fruit nuances, making it a contender for the title of "premier Añejo Tequila."
The intricate complexity of ArteNom 1146 caters to seasoned tequila enthusiasts. The aroma and taste boast abundant notes of dried fruit, chocolate, and roasted nuts, setting it apart as one of the finest in its category.
Arette Gran Clase: An Extra Añejo Tequila with Enduring Agave Character
Arette Gran Clase stands out among Extra Añejos with its exceptional balance.
The aroma evokes bourbon, with enticing notes of caramel and vanilla followed by a hint of orange and apricot. The first sip reveals a luxuriously oily texture that caresses the palate. While packing a warming punch due to its 104-proof bottling (compared to the standard 80 proof), it's surprisingly smooth.
The true star of the show is the agave. Despite extensive aging, the agave flavor remains prominent, harmonizing beautifully with the vanilla and caramel sweetness. Robust baking spices and subtle oak notes add complexity to the profile. The long, warming finish lingers with pleasant oak and baking spice nuances.
Arette Gran Clase achieves this balance by remaining entirely natural, free from additives and artificial flavors. This commitment to quality, along with its attractive price point for an Extra Añejo tequila, makes it a remarkable value.
If you're seeking a sipping tequila with a rich agave character that integrates seamlessly with aged spirit notes, look no further than Arette Gran Clase. It's a worthy addition to any collection or home bar.
Tears of Llorona: A Masterful Extra Añejo Tequila
Tears of Llorona's rich, deep color hints at the exceptional complexity that awaits. The first sip surprises with a light mouthfeel and gentle warmth, allowing the intricate flavors to take center stage.
This is a sipping tequila in the truest sense, a harmonious fusion of smoky, oaky, sweet, and spicy notes that unfold beautifully on the palate. The finish, though brief, is elevated by the slightly higher proof (86 proof compared to the standard 80 proof).
The secret to Tears of Llorona's magic lies in its aging process. Nearly five years in a combination of Scotch, sherry, and cognac barrels imbue it with a distinct character. Despite exceeding the typical tequila proof, it stays smooth and eminently drinkable, free from any harsh bite.
Overall, Tears of Llorona stands out as an exceptional Extra Añejo tequila, a must-have for any serious tequila collector or enthusiast looking to add a top-shelf tequila to their repertoire.
How to Choose a Good Tequila for Collecting
Collecting Tequila can be a rewarding hobby, offering a chance to explore the depth and variety of this rich spirit.
Whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting, understanding how to choose collectible Tequilas is key.
Here's a guide to help you curate your collection.
Understanding the Appeal of Collectible Tequilas
- Unique Flavor Profiles: Look for Tequilas with distinctive flavors and aging processes. Each bottle should bring something special to your collection.
- Limited Editions and Artisanal Brands: Limited releases and artisanal brands often hold more value and interest for collectors. They are not only unique but can also become rarer over time.
- Brand Reputation and Heritage: Brands with a long-standing reputation and history in Tequila production are often sought after. Their legacy often contributes to the value of their bottles.
- Aging and Cask Selection: Tequilas aged in unique casks (like bourbon, wine, or sherry barrels) can offer intriguing flavors. Extra Añejo or aged expressions are particularly collectible due to their complexity and rarity.
- Additive-Free: Pure, additive-free Tequilas are often more desirable for collectors, as they offer a more authentic taste of the agave plant.
- Presentation and Packaging: Bottles with unique or artistic designs can be more attractive as collectibles. They not only look great on display but can also add to the bottle's value.
Tips for Building a Tequila Collection
- Diverse Selection: Aim for a variety of styles and brands to create a well-rounded collection.
- Research: Stay informed about new releases and limited editions. Joining Tequila enthusiast groups or forums can be helpful.
- Storage: Store your Tequila bottles upright, away from direct sunlight and in a consistent temperature to preserve their quality.
- Budgeting: Set a budget for your collection. While some bottles can be pricey, there are many hidden gems that are more affordable.
- Tasting and Sharing: Part of collecting is enjoying and sharing your Tequilas. Consider hosting tasting sessions to appreciate the different profiles.
Where to Purchase Collectible Tequilas
- Specialty Liquor Stores: Often have a more curated selection, including limited editions.
- Online Retailers: Websites like oldtowntequila.com, astorwines.com, totalwine.com, and drizly.com offer a wide range of options and can sometimes have exclusive bottles.
- Tequila Distilleries: Visiting distilleries can provide opportunities to purchase exclusive or limited bottles directly.
Conclusion
Building a Tequila collection is a journey of discovery and appreciation. Focus on quality, uniqueness, and personal preference. Remember, the best collection is one that reflects your taste and passion for Tequila. Enjoy the process of exploring and adding new bottles to your collection, and don't forget to savor and share your discoveries along the way.